-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 6
Agent Framework Comparisons
TrueMagic edited this page Apr 21, 2025
·
11 revisions
Feature | Solana Agent | OpenAI Agents SDK |
---|---|---|
Architecture | Service-oriented with query routing | Agent-based with explicit handoffs |
Configuration | JSON-based config with minimal code | Python code-based agent definitions |
Multi-Agent | Automatic specialization routing | Direct agent-to-agent handoffs |
Memory | Integrated MongoDB/Zep persistence | In-context memory within message history |
Multi-Modal | Full audio/text streaming built-in | Optional voice support via add-on package |
Model Support | OpenAI only | Any provider with OpenAI-compatible API |
Tool Integration | Class-based tools with registry | Function decorators with @function_tool
|
Debugging | Pydantic Logfire, OpenAI logging, and terminal | Tracing with visualization |
Output Handling | Streaming yield pattern | Structured output types with validation |
Business Focus | Business mission/values framework | General purpose agent framework |
Feature | Solana Agent | LangGraph |
---|---|---|
Architecture | Service-oriented with agents | Graph-based state machine |
Workflow Design | Implicit routing by specialization | Explicit node connections and state transitions |
Learning Curve | Simple setup with config objects | Steeper with graph concepts and states |
Streaming | Native streaming for all I/O | Requires additional configuration |
Visualization | None built-in | Graph visualization of agent workflows |
State Management | Implicit state via memory | Explicit state transitions and persistence |
Integration | Standalone framework | Part of LangChain ecosystem |
Flexibility | Fixed routing paradigm | Highly customizable flow control |
Feature | Solana Agent | CrewAI |
---|---|---|
Multi-Agent Design | Specialist agents with router | Agent crews with explicit roles |
Agent Interaction | Query router determines agent | Direct agent-to-agent delegation |
Configuration | JSON-based configuration | Python class-based agent definitions |
Task Structure | Query-based interactions | Task-based with goals and workflows |
Memory Sharing | Shared memory store | Agent-specific memories |
Human Interaction | Built for direct human queries | Designed for autonomous operation |
Streaming | Native streaming support | Limited streaming support |
Team Dynamics | Flat specialist structure | Hierarchical with managers and workers |
Feature | Solana Agent | PydanticAI |
---|---|---|
Multi-Modal | Full audio/text streaming built-in | Text output only, input depends on LLM |
Memory | Built-in conversation history | Not included |
Multi-Agent | First-class multi-agent support | Single agent focus with composition patterns |
Tool Creation | Python classes with execute method | Function decorators with schema |
Model Support | OpenAI only | Integrates with many LLMs |
Flow Control | Implicit routing | Python control flow with graph support |
- You need a simple, quick-to-deploy agent system.
- Multi-modal support (text/audio) is essential.
- You want automatic routing between specialized agents.
- Business mission alignment is important.
- You prefer configuration over code.
- Persistent memory across conversations is needed.
- You want streaming responses out of the box.
- You need detailed tracing for debugging complex agent workflows.
- You want explicit control over agent handoffs.
- Your architecture requires structured output validation.
- You're using multiple LLM providers with OpenAI-compatible APIs.
- You prefer a code-first approach to agent definition.
- You need complex, multi-step workflows with branching logic.
- Your use case requires explicit state management.
- You want to visualize the flow of your agent system.
- You're already in the LangChain ecosystem.
- You need fine-grained control over agent decision paths.
- Your application has complex conditional flows.
- You want to model your agent system as a state machine.
- You need agents to work together with minimal human input.
- Your use case involves complex team collaboration.
- You need hierarchical task delegation between agents.
- You want agents with specific roles and responsibilities.
- Your application requires autonomous operation.
- You need explicit agent-to-agent communication.
- Your workflow involves complex multi-step tasks.
- You want to use multiple LLM providers in one codebase.
- You require structured responses with validation guarantees.
- Your application needs dependency injection for easier testing.
- You want to leverage your existing Pydantic knowledge.
- You need both simple control flow and complex graph capabilities.