Skip to content

Commit 6a650f7

Browse files
tonytony
committed
notes(test-audit[2025-03-08]) Add test-audit file
1 parent 4ae62d8 commit 6a650f7

File tree

1 file changed

+146
-0
lines changed

1 file changed

+146
-0
lines changed

‎notes/2025-03-08 - test-audit.md

Lines changed: 146 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,146 @@
1+
# VCSPull Test Coverage Audit
2+
3+
## Overview
4+
5+
VCSPull has an overall test coverage of 85%, which is good but not comprehensive. The codebase has 58 tests spread across 6 test files focusing on different aspects of the application.
6+
7+
## Coverage Metrics
8+
9+
```
10+
Name Stmts Miss Branch BrPart Cover Missing
11+
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
12+
conftest.py 39 8 4 1 79% 31-32, 91-98
13+
src/vcspull/_internal/config_reader.py 39 5 12 3 84% 50, 69, 114, 160, 189
14+
src/vcspull/cli/sync.py 85 14 34 11 79% 29, 61, 76->78, 81, 89, 91, 109-111, 115, 129-130, 132-133, 142, 151->153, 153->155, 160
15+
src/vcspull/config.py 148 10 88 13 89% 105, 107->110, 110->117, 121, 128-131, 151->153, 220->235, 266, 281, 307, 342->344, 344->347, 424
16+
src/vcspull/log.py 55 8 4 1 85% 39, 67-96, 105-106
17+
src/vcspull/validator.py 18 6 16 6 65% 17, 21, 24, 27, 31, 34
18+
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
19+
TOTAL 414 51 170 35 85%
20+
```
21+
22+
## Feature Coverage Analysis
23+
24+
### Well-Tested Features
25+
26+
1. **CLI Interface** (test_cli.py - 21 tests)
27+
- Command-line arguments processing
28+
- Filter pattern handling for repositories
29+
- Exit code handling for various scenarios
30+
- Output validation for different commands
31+
- Error handling for non-existent repositories
32+
- Testing broken repository scenarios
33+
34+
2. **Configuration File Management** (test_config_file.py - 17 tests)
35+
- Reading YAML and JSON configurations
36+
- Finding configuration files in various locations
37+
- Parameter validation
38+
- Path expansion logic
39+
- XDG config directory support
40+
- Home directory configuration files
41+
- File type filtering (yaml vs json)
42+
- Pattern matching for config files
43+
44+
3. **Configuration Processing** (test_config.py - 2 tests)
45+
- Configuration format validation
46+
- Support for relative directories
47+
48+
4. **Repository Filtering** (test_repo.py - 6 tests)
49+
- Filtering repositories by directory path
50+
- Filtering repositories by name
51+
- Filtering repositories by VCS URL
52+
- Converting configuration dictionaries to repository objects
53+
- URL scheme handling for different VCS types (git, hg, svn)
54+
55+
5. **Synchronization** (test_sync.py - 9 tests)
56+
- Directory creation during sync
57+
- Remote repository handling
58+
- Configuration variations
59+
- Remote updating functionality
60+
61+
6. **Utilities** (test_utils.py - 3 tests)
62+
- Config directory environment variable handling
63+
- XDG config directory support
64+
- Fallback path handling
65+
66+
### Partially Tested Features
67+
68+
1. **Error Handling** (79-85% coverage across files)
69+
- Missing coverage for specific error conditions
70+
- Some edge cases in error handling not tested
71+
- Error recovery flows partially tested
72+
73+
2. **URL Processing**
74+
- Basic URL scheme detection well tested
75+
- Some edge cases in URL parsing not fully covered
76+
- URL normalization handling partially tested
77+
78+
3. **Repository Update Logic**
79+
- Happy path and basic functionality well tested
80+
- Some conditional branches in update_repo function not fully covered
81+
- Specific VCS operation error cases partially tested
82+
83+
### Minimally Tested Areas
84+
85+
1. **Validator Module** (65% coverage)
86+
- Configuration validation has minimal test coverage
87+
- Validation error conditions mostly untested
88+
- Error messages and reporting minimally tested
89+
90+
2. **Logging Configuration** (85% coverage but specific sections missing)
91+
- Log level configuration partially tested
92+
- Log formatting and output handling minimally tested
93+
94+
3. **Shell Command Execution**
95+
- Post-repo updates shell commands minimally tested
96+
- Error handling in command execution has gaps
97+
98+
## Notable Coverage Gaps
99+
100+
1. **Validator Module**
101+
- Lines 17, 21, 24, 27, 31, 34 - Missing validation error paths
102+
- Configuration validation edge cases not fully tested
103+
104+
2. **CLI Sync Module**
105+
- Lines 76-78, 109-111, 129-130, 132-133 - Error handling branches
106+
- Line 160 - Final repository return handling
107+
- Lines 151-155 - URL processing conditional branches
108+
109+
3. **Config Reader**
110+
- Lines 50, 69, 114, 160, 189 - Error handling and format detection
111+
112+
4. **Logging**
113+
- Lines 67-96, 105-106 - Log configuration and output handling
114+
115+
## Recommendations
116+
117+
1. **Improve Validator Testing**
118+
- Add tests for invalid configuration formats
119+
- Test edge cases in configuration validation
120+
- Ensure error messages are properly generated
121+
122+
2. **Enhance Error Handling Tests**
123+
- Test more error conditions in sync operations
124+
- Cover branch conditions in URL processing
125+
- Test recovery from failed operations
126+
127+
3. **Expand Logging Tests**
128+
- Test different log levels and configurations
129+
- Verify log output formatting
130+
- Test log handling during errors
131+
132+
4. **Add Integration Tests**
133+
- Test end-to-end workflows across real repositories
134+
- Test against actual Git/SVN/Mercurial services
135+
- Test more complex repository structures
136+
137+
5. **Test Shell Command Execution**
138+
- Verify post-update commands execute correctly
139+
- Test command failure scenarios
140+
- Test environment variable handling in commands
141+
142+
## Conclusion
143+
144+
VCSPull has a solid test foundation covering most core functionality, but has gaps in validation, error handling, and some specific conditional paths. The project would benefit from targeted tests for these areas to improve overall reliability and maintainability.
145+
146+
The CLI interface and configuration management are thoroughly tested, while validation and some error handling paths could use additional coverage. The 85% overall coverage is good, but strategic improvements in the identified areas would strengthen the test suite significantly.

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)