Skip to content

Review Guidelines

Chito Wong edited this page Jul 13, 2025 · 16 revisions

This checklist helps ensure all community-submitted templates meet our standards for quality and accuracy.

Usage

Please copy the following Markdown content to the issue, and select available items.

- [ ] not selected
- [x] selected

will be displayed as

  • not selected
  • selected

English Version

## Basic Requirements
- [ ] A Pull Request has been created and linked to the relevant issue.
- [ ] All lines are officially open or to be open, verified by:
    - [ ] Images are uploaded directly to the issue.
    - [ ] Videos are uploaded to a video-sharing platform (e.g., YouTube, BiliBili).
    - [ ] Images or videos from social media platforms are properly linked and viewable.
- [ ] All stations and interchanges shown on route maps in the submission are fully and accurately represented according to the provided sources.

## Accuracy
- [ ] All station names are spelled correctly.
- [ ] Interchanges are complete and accurate as of the submission date.
- [ ] Direction, platform numbers, platform screen door (PSD) numbers, and coach numbers are correct and logical.
- [ ] (For MTR, Guangzhou Metro, and Shanghai Metro only) The template's style perfectly matches the real-life route map.

## Aesthetic
- [ ] Sensible and consistent spacing is used in the template.

## Others
- [ ] The submission type is new line submission.
- [ ] The submission type is update to existing lines.
- [ ] If this is an update, the changes are incremental rather than a complete replacement unless explicitly intended as such.
- [ ] There are no other issues submitted earlier of these same lines that have passed review.

简体中文版本

请将以下内容复制至议题中,并选中适用的项目。

## 基本要求
- [ ] 已为该议题创建并链接了 Pull Request (拉取请求)。
- [ ] 提交內容中的路线已向公众开放,或即将开放。由以下方式验证:
    - [ ] 图片已直接上传至议题中。
    - [ ] 视频已上传至视频分享平台(例如:YouTube、BiliBili)。
    - [ ] 来自社交媒体平台的图片或视频已正确链接且可查看。
- [ ] 提交内容中线路图上显示的所有车站和换乘点,都根据所提供的来源进行了完整且准确的呈现。

## 准确性
- [ ] 所有车站名称拼写无误。
- [ ] 换乘信息在提交时是完整且正确的。
- [ ] 方向、站台编号、站台闸门 (PSD) 编号和车厢编号正确或合理。
- [ ] (仅适用于港铁、广州地铁和上海地铁) 模板样式与实际线路图完全匹配。

## 美观性
- [ ] 模板整体使用了合理且一致的间距,以确保可读性和视觉美观。

## 其他
- [ ] 提交类型为新线路提交。
- [ ] 提交类型为现有线路更新。
- [ ] 如果这是更新,则更改应是增量式的,而非完整替换,除非明确意图如此。
- [ ] 没有任何更早提交的议题井已通过审核的相同线路的提交。

繁體中文版本

請將以下內容複製至議題中,並選中適用的項目。

## 基本要求
- [ ] 已為該議題創建並連結了 Pull Request (拉取請求)。
- [ ] 提交內容中路線已向公眾開放,或即將開放。由以下方式驗證:
    - [ ] 圖片已直接上傳至議題中。
    - [ ] 影片已上傳至影音分享平台(例如:YouTube、BiliBili)。
    - [ ] 來自社群媒體平台的圖片或影片已正確連結且可檢視。
- [ ] 提交內容中路線圖上顯示的所有車站和轉乘點,都根據所提供的來源進行了完整且準確的呈現。

## 準確性
- [ ] 所有車站名稱拼寫無誤。
- [ ] 轉乘資訊在提交時是完整且正確的。
- [ ] 方向、月台編號、月台閘門 (PSD) 編號和車廂編號正確或合理。
- [ ] (僅適用於港鐵、廣州地鐵和上海地鐵) 模板樣式與實際路線圖完全匹配。

## 美觀性
- [ ] 模板整體使用了合理的間距,以確保可讀性和視覺美觀。

## 其他
- [ ] 提交類型為新路線提交。
- [ ] 提交類型為現有路線更新。
- [ ] 如果這是更新,則更改應是增量式的,而非完整替換,除非明確意圖如此。
- [ ] 沒有任何更早提交的議題並已通過審核的相同路線的提交。
Clone this wiki locally