Skip to content

Commit 3d8ebb6

Browse files
authored
Merge pull request #340 from per1234/update-moderator-instructions
Update "Moderator Instructions" to reflect changes to forum UI
2 parents 3d16d5c + 6d25c75 commit 3d8ebb6

File tree

1 file changed

+20
-21
lines changed
  • content/categories/staff/moderation/_topics/moderator-instructions

1 file changed

+20
-21
lines changed

content/categories/staff/moderation/_topics/moderator-instructions/1.md

Lines changed: 20 additions & 21 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -59,15 +59,15 @@ For an overview of the Discourse moderation system, see the **[Discourse Moderat
5959

6060
Flags are used to bring things to the attention of the moderators. They may be submitted [by forum users](#user-submitted-flags) or [by automated systems](#automated-system-submitted-flags).
6161

62-
Flags are shown on the ["Review" page](https://forum.arduino.cc/review). A moderators must review each flag and decide how it should be handled.
62+
Flags are shown on the ["Review" page](https://forum.arduino.cc/review). A moderator must review each flag and decide how it should be handled.
6363

6464
**Note:** there are some conditions where mention of products or services is allowed and not considered spam, which are listed [here](#exceptions).
6565

6666
<a name="user-submitted-flags"></a>
6767

6868
### [User-submitted flags](#user-submitted-flags)
6969

70-
Users can flag any post by clicking the **⬤⬤⬤** icon, then the **:black_flag:**. Multiple flags result in the post being automatically hidden and eventually deleted, without any moderator action.
70+
Users can flag any post by clicking the **:black_flag:** icon. The post may be automatically locked and/or hidden pending review based on the number of flags and ["trust level"](https://blog.discourse.org/2018/06/understanding-discourse-trust-levels/) of the flaggers.
7171

7272
When submitting a flag, the user selects the category of the reason for the flag, which is shown on the ["Review" page](https://forum.arduino.cc/review).
7373

@@ -77,10 +77,9 @@ When submitting a flag, the user selects the category of the reason for the flag
7777

7878
The ["Review" page](https://forum.arduino.cc/review) presents four options for handling user-submitted flags:
7979

80-
- **Agree...** - the flag was correct and the post was in violation of forum rules. The author of the flagged post will be [penalized](https://blog.discourse.org/2018/06/understanding-discourse-trust-levels/).
81-
- **Disagree** - the flag was incorrect. The user who submitted the flag will be penalized.
82-
- **Ignore** - the flag was correct, but didn't indicate a problem with the flagged post. Nobody is penalized. If the post was automatically hidden by the flag, it will remain hidden.
83-
- **Delete...** - the flagged post should be deleted. The dropdown menu offers "**Delete Post and Ignore**" and "**Delete Post and Agree**" options, which have the effects on the author of the flagged post documented above.
80+
- **Yes ▾** - the flag was correct and the post was in violation of forum rules. The author of the flagged post will be [penalized](https://blog.discourse.org/2018/06/understanding-discourse-trust-levels/).
81+
- **No** - the flag was incorrect. The user who submitted the flag will be penalized.
82+
- **Ignore ▾** - the flag was correct, but didn't indicate a problem with the flagged post. Nobody is penalized. If the post was automatically hidden by the flag, it will remain hidden.
8483

8584
---
8685

@@ -108,15 +107,15 @@ See the [**"Inappropriate behavior"**](#deal-with-inappropriate-behavior) instru
108107

109108
##### [If the post is not spam](#if-the-post-is-not-spam)
110109

111-
1. Click the **<kbd>:-1: Disagree</kbd>** button.
110+
1. Click the **<kbd>No</kbd>** button.
112111

113112
<a name="if-the-post-is-spam"></a>
114113

115114
##### [If the post is spam](#if-the-post-is-spam)
116115

117-
1. Click the **<kbd>:+1: Agree...</kbd>** button.
118-
1. From the dropdown menu, click **Suspend User**. The **"Suspend User"** dialog will open.
119-
1. From the **Select a timeframe** dropdown menu, select **Forever**.
116+
1. Click the **<kbd>Yes ▾</kbd>** button.
117+
1. From the dropdown menu, click **Suspend user**. The **"Suspend User"** dialog will open.
118+
1. From the **Suspend user until** dropdown menu, select **Forever**.
120119
1. In the **Suspension Reason** text field, enter "spam".
121120
1. From the **"What would you like to do with the associated post?"** dropdown menu, select **Delete the post**.
122121
1. Click the **<kbd>:no_entry_sign: Suspend</kbd>** button.
@@ -130,7 +129,7 @@ See the [**"Inappropriate behavior"**](#deal-with-inappropriate-behavior) instru
130129
The user submitting a "Something Else" flag will provide a message explaining the purpose of the flag. This might be used to flag problematic posts that don't fit into any of the standard user-submitted flag categories, or simply as an efficient means of communicating with the moderators about a benign post (e.g., requesting a tutorial topic be closed to discussion).
131130

132131
1. [Review the flag](#review-flag).
133-
1. If the flag warranted action, resolve it, following the relevant instructions provided elsewhere in this document. In cases where an **"Agree"** review was warranted but you are unable to take the external action to resolve the flag, just select **"Keep Post"** from the **<kbd>:+1: Agree...</kbd>** menu. A message is generated in the [**"Moderators"** messages folder](https://forum.arduino.cc/my/messages/group/moderators) for each "Something Else" flag, and this message will be used to track the request. If the flag was resolved by the review process itself
132+
1. If the flag warranted action, resolve it, following the relevant instructions provided elsewhere in this document. In cases where an **"Yes"** review was warranted but you are unable to take the external action to resolve the flag, just select **"Keep post"** from the **<kbd>Yes ▾</kbd>** menu. A message is generated in the [**"Moderators"** messages folder](https://forum.arduino.cc/my/messages/group/moderators) for each "Something Else" flag, and this message will be used to track the request.
134133
1. A private message is generated for each "Something Else" flag. This can be accessed directly via the flag's **<kbd>view full conversation</kbd>** button, or the [**"Moderators"** messages folder](https://forum.arduino.cc/my/messages/group/moderators). If the flag was resolved by the review interface itself, this message will automatically be archived. However, it is often not possible to resolve the flag via the review interface (e.g., [moving](#move-topic-to-correct-category) a topic to the appropriate category). In this case, the message must be manually archived by clicking its **<kbd>:file_folder: Archive</kbd>** button.
135134

136135
![Archive message|356x500, 50%](https://europe1.discourse-cdn.com/arduino/original/4X/0/e/c/0ec0938faf6e77029655ff167701d3ca16bbdd3f.png)
@@ -199,14 +198,14 @@ This flag is created by `@system` when a post is detected as possibly spam by [A
199198

200199
##### [If the post is benign](#if-the-post-is-benign-1)
201200

202-
1. Click the **<kbd>:-1: Not Spam</kbd>** button.
201+
1. Click the **<kbd>Not Spam</kbd>** button.
203202

204203
<a name="if-the-post-is-malicious-1"></a>
205204

206205
##### [If the post is malicious](#if-the-post-is-malicious-1)
207206

208-
1. Click the **<kbd>:+1: Agree...</kbd>** button.
209-
1. From the dropdown menu, select **Confirm Spam & Suspend User**.
207+
1. Click the **<kbd>Yes ▾</kbd>** button.
208+
1. From the dropdown menu, select **Suspend User**.
210209

211210
---
212211

@@ -266,9 +265,9 @@ Mentions of relevant products or services of interest to the Arduino community a
266265
1. Click the **⬤⬤⬤** icon at the bottom of the spam post.
267266
1. Click the **:black_flag:** icon.
268267
1. Click the **It's Spam** radio button.
269-
1. Click the **<kbd>Take Action...</kbd>** button.
268+
1. Click the **<kbd>Take Action...</kbd>** button.
270269
1. From the dropdown menu, click **Suspend User**. The **"Suspend User"** dialog will open.
271-
1. From the **Select a timeframe** dropdown menu, select **Forever**.
270+
1. From the **Suspend user until** dropdown menu, select **Forever**.
272271
1. In the **Suspension Reason** text field, enter "spam".
273272
1. From the **"What would you like to do with the associated post?"** dropdown menu, select **Delete the post**.
274273
1. Click the **<kbd>:no_entry_sign: Suspend</kbd>** button.
@@ -371,7 +370,7 @@ A topic hijack is when a user makes a reply that is not relevant to the topic. T
371370

372371
### [Reopen auto-closed topic](#reopen-auto-closed-topic)
373372

374-
When four months have passed since the last reply to a topic, it is automatically closed and non-staff forum users are prevented from replying. Forum users may request topics be unlocked by raising a "Something Else" flag against the topic.
373+
When six months have passed since the last reply to a topic, it is automatically closed and non-staff forum users are prevented from replying. Forum users may request topics be unlocked by raising a "Something Else" flag against the topic.
375374

376375
When a reopen request flag is received, it should be reviewed to determine whether reopening the topic would be appropriate.
377376

@@ -387,8 +386,8 @@ When a reopen request flag is received, it should be reviewed to determine wheth
387386
> The topic has now been reopened.
388387
1. Click the <kbd>**:email: Message**</kbd> button.
389388
1. Go back to [the flag review page](https://forum.arduino.cc/review).
390-
1. Click the <kbd>**Ignore**</kbd> button on the flag message.
391-
**Note:** the <kbd>**:+1: Agree...**</kbd> button should not be used because this would result in an unwarranted strike against the topic author.
389+
1. Click the <kbd>**Ignore**</kbd> button on the flag message.
390+
**Note:** the <kbd>**Yes ▾**</kbd> button should not be used because this would result in an unwarranted strike against the topic author.
392391

393392
##### If reopening is not appropriate
394393

@@ -398,7 +397,7 @@ When a reopen request flag is received, it should be reviewed to determine wheth
398397
> We have decided to leave the topic closed. Please [create a new topic](https://forum.arduino.cc/t/how-to-get-the-best-out-of-this-forum/679966#first-post).
399398
1. Click the <kbd>**:email: Message**</kbd> button.
400399
1. Go back to [the flag review page](https://forum.arduino.cc/review).
401-
1. Click the <kbd>**:-1: Disagree**</kbd> button.
400+
1. Click the <kbd>**No**</kbd> button.
402401

403402
---
404403

@@ -612,7 +611,7 @@ Account suspensions are used when the intention is to permanently exclude the us
612611
1. Open the user's profile page. This can be accessed by clicking their user name, then the user name in the profile preview popup.
613612
1. Click the **<kbd>Admin</kbd>** button.
614613
1. From the **Permissions** section, click the **<kbd>:no_entry_sign: Suspend</kbd>** button.
615-
1. From the **Select a timeframe** dropdown menu, select **Forever**.
614+
1. From the **Suspend user until** dropdown menu, select **Forever**.
616615
1. In the **Suspension Reason** text field, enter a short explanation for the cause of suspension (e.g., "spam").
617616
1. Click the **<kbd>:no_entry_sign: Suspend</kbd>** button.
618617

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)