Why does Aptos Compiler allow custom structs in Entry Functions despite SDK limitations?

[lumos42]

While I've seen at a bunch of places that entry functions support only native types, aptos compiler allows for having custom structs in entry functions too. Is this a missed check in the compiler?

for example, i'm able to create a function like this:

public entry fun create_pool<T: drop + store + copy>(
        sender: &signer,
        name: String,
        token: Object<Metadata>,
        deposit_cap: u128,
        rate_model: u8,
        rate_model_data: T
)

It lets me compile, and deploy this function, and also use it in move scripts, but there's no support in aptos-sdk to call this function. So it this allowed or not?

I've already seen a few discussions/comments that custom structs are not supported. My question is - why does the compiler allow for it?

1. When will we support custom struct in function parameters and response? #275
2. SimpleMap in move #176 (comment)

[kshitijc1506]

You're referring to passing T as a param?

From what I can tell this compiles but will give a runtime error if T is a custom struct. Probably, it's the case that custom types can compile because the compiler doesn't enforce runtime execution checks around external transaction signing, serialization, and deserialization for complex custom types.

[lumos42]

@kshitjee I tried calling the create_pool function from a move script, and it worked. You can see the transaction here:

https://explorer.aptoslabs.com/txn/0x21353a10fd9d8c235ed92228afa877e7fd5d27d531faf5e2069ccc3a8ffb2aef?network=testnet

[kshitijc1506]

Also, in the future, could you pls change the categories of questions you're posting to "Questions"? Really appreciate, thx 🙏