[Bug] karatemplater doesn't compute the right syllable styles

[red5h4d0w]

When Applying Karaoke Template, the computed syl.style does not match the intended style when a \rStyle Name tag was used.

Example:

Using the template syl line {\an5\pos(!line.left+syl.center!,!$middle!)\k!$start/10!\r!syl.style.name!\k$skdur}, the computed style should be enforced on the generated lines.

Before applying the the karaoke template:

After application:

Link to the example file I made to highlight the issue: example file.ass

[arch1t3cht]

I'm not sure if the templater really should do that. I can see the use case, of course, but this feels out of bounds for the templater (which only really splits lines into syllables and doesn't have special handling for any other tags either). At the very least, this is not a bug, at most a feature request.

If you wanted to, you could make your template do this using inline fx, i.e. replace your \rFoo tags by \-Foo and put something like {\r!syl.inline_fx!} at the start of your template.

[red5h4d0w]

Okay I was under the impression that it was intended to compute syllable style, since there is no use for syl.style when it will always be the same as line.style (from what I understand).

I'll open a new ticket as a feature request.

[FichteFoll]

syl.X is mostly identical to line.X because it is cloned from it and can be used as the main entry point for any syl template. Only the syllable-specific properties are updated for individual syl iteration.

[red5h4d0w]

syl.X is mostly identical to line.X because it is cloned from it and can be used as the main entry point for any syl template. Only the syllable-specific properties are updated for individual syl iteration.

My point was that style could be syllable specific if reset style tags were used and this is what I adressed in PR #313