Skip to content

Cropped ISIS Cube and ALE Generated ISD #601

@jlaura

Description

@jlaura

When running the following pipeline, I am getting unexpected results. Talking with @acpaquette these results are sensical because of how ISIS implements cropping.

Here is the pipeline:

  • Generate an ISIS cube
  • Crop the cube and propagate SPICE
  • Use isd_generate to create an ISD from the cropped cube

My expected behavior is that the ISD generated by isd_generate will be appropriate to use with the cropped ISIS cube. By appropriate, I mean that a campt call and some knoten sensor model function will return the same results, plus or minus the accepted tolerance. In reality, the results are quite different. Why?

ISIS tracks the offsets in the cropped cube and carries around the full observation SPICE. Therefore, the ISD created by ALE is the full observation SPICE. But, the cropped cube is just that, a cropped image. The CSM has no idea that the ISD is provided for an uncropped image.

The result is that a test to ensure that say, pixel (10,10) in the cropped ISIS image returns the same lon/lat between both campt and knoten requires that I add whatever the start sample/line used for the crop command. That information is not recorded in the ISD. It is available via cathist.

I do not know that I have a suggested fix. Options that come to mind (without a lot of thought about the trickle down effects):

  • "Fix" ISIS so that a cropped cube crops the SPICE as well. (I say "fix" because I think ISIS is working as intended.)
  • Fix isd_generate to create a proper cropped ISD if the input ISIS cube is cropped

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

No labels
No labels

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions